Quick Comic Reviews

We3 #3

by Grant Morrison & Frank Quitely

It is possible at this point to heap more suprelatives on Morrison & Quitely's masterpiece? Probably not. But over the course of 96 pages, they have managed to redefine comic book action, proving that you can be exciting and thought-provoking and innovative all at the same time. Heck, just look at the way Quitely uses foreground shadows to blead into the panel borders, for instance. I predict that this comic is one that will be analyzed and dissected for years to come. I only gave the first two installments of this mini a 4 out of 5, but that was because it was an incomplete at the time. Taken together, these three issues add up to more than the sum of their parts. So a 4.5 for the tale, and I reserve to right to raise that higher at some point.

Rating: 4.5 (of 5)




Termporary #1: "Cubes and Ladders"

by Damon Hurd & Rick Smith

Temporary promises to tell the adventures of Envy Saint-Claire, twenty-seomthing temp worker who likes her life as an itenerant; she enjoys spending a day sitting in someone else's life (sort of a Christopher Chance for the boring office-drone set). This first issue finds Envy in a strange cube farm where the employees all seem to be genuinely crazy. It's a nice commentary on the drudgery of middle-corporate America. As for the art by Smith, it's not his strongest effort: the characters are often stiff and the backgrounds are scant. It gets the story across, but that's about it. His art on his own Baraka and Black Magic in Morocco was much better. But in all this looks to be a promising series.

Rating: 3 (of 5)




Pigtale #1

by Ovi Nedelcu

I've never heard of Nedelcu before, but based on the style and confidence of his art (not to mention the testimonials in lieu of a letters page) I'm assuming that he's the latest animator dipping his toes into comic books. Though it's all set-up so far, this first issue introduces us to Boston Booth, nebbish twenty-seomthing who wants to be a private investigator, and the talking pig who looks to be his partner. As the pig isn't introduced until the last page it's hard to tell how successful the pairing will be, but based on the strong characterizations and storytelling ability that Nedelcu shows (especially in the exciting chase scene) I'm looking forward to seeing how it all develops. It's a good start--I just hope that the origin tale doesn't drag out too long...

Rating: 3 (of 5)

Monkey Covers

Sunday is Monkey Covers day here at YACB. Because there's nothing better than a comic with a monkey on the cover.

From 1958's Action Comics #238, artists Curt Swan & Stan Kaye give us Superman vs. King Krypton, the Super-Gorilla. So, you're a talking super-powered gorilla from Krypton, and he best you can do is to hit Superman over the head with a log? How lame! Man, even Beppo could kick your hairy butt. (And how is it that the log doesn't just shatter on hitting Superman's super-hard skull?)

(standard disclaimer about gorillas not really being monkeys applies)

Image is courtesy of the GCD. Click on the image for a larger version.

Lost in Translation

Back in March 2002, I had the opportunity to visit Japan as a guest of the University of Library and Information Science in Tsukuba Science City (yes, that's right: "Tsukuba Science City"!) to make a presentation at one of their Digital Library Workshops. (If you're interested, the paper based on my presentation can be found here.)



Like most American comic book fans, I had this image of Japan as some sort of Paradise of comics. It was a place where manga was available on every street corner, where men, women and children all sat in the park or on the subway reading comics, where comic creators were exaulted like sports heroes or rock stars.



As it turned out, the truth was far different. I only once saw manga anthologies on sale at a newsstand, and I never saw anyone reading manga in public.



Granted, I only spent a little over four days in Japan--three days in Tsukuba and one day in Tokyo--and I didn't have much time to go wandering off on my own. So it is possible that I just completely missed all the manga, though it was fairly obvious that comics weren't as all-pervasive as we are often led to believe.



It wasn't a completely comic-free visit though. On my trip into Tokyo my guides were two female Korean graduate students of my host professor's, and on the bus ride back I got into a discussion about manga with one of the women (a discussion somewhat hampered by my not knowing the original Japanese titles of many of the things I had read in English). The impression that I got from her was that comic reading wasn't at all unusual, that just about everyone read manga occasionally.



The one other time I did see manga was in a rental store; alongside videos and music cds one could also rent books, including some manga collections.



Other interesting pop culture observations from that trip:



At a dinner with two of the Professors from the University, we got off into a discussion about television. They asked which if any Japanese programs made it onto American television. I said that back in my youth we got Ultraman, Johnny Socko and the like, and that we got a good deal of anime. BUt that the only other Japanese show that was on American tv was Iron Chef--they were horrified.



Speaking of television, my hotel room (very small!) only got two stations with any English-language programming: one was BBC News, and the other had various American TV shows which could be listened to either in English or dubbed into Japanese (chosen by a switch on the remote). But no matter which option you chose, all the the promotional advertising was in Japanese, and some of the ads were very odd. The spots for Babylon 5 in particular made the show look very unlike the show I was familiar with, and more like an anime space opera with an almost fetishistic attention paid to the various spacecraft.



At one point one of the non-English stations was showing a press event from the promotinoal tour of on of the Lord of the Rings movies. They would show the questions by the press being asked in Japanese, edit out the translation of the questions into English, then show the responses in English and the translation back into Japanese. So essentially I could only understand the responses by the cast without knowing what questions precipitated the responses, which sometimes made things a bit baffling.



(I was inspired to finally write this post after reading a post by Shawn Fumo.)

Quick DC GN Reviews

Superman: Secret Identity

by Kurt Busiek & Stuart Immonen

Chance are you've already read several glowing reviews of this story, so I'll just say that those reviews are right: this is one of the best Superman stories in many years. Inspired by a nearly two-decades old story from DC Comics Presents about the Superboy of Earth-Prime, Busiek spins the tale of a real-world Clark Kent. Young Kent is teased about his name, but is surprised when he unexpectedly develops the super powers of his namesake. But instead of going public, Clark keeps his powers a secret, even as his life follows a vaguely parallel path as that of the fictional Clark Kent. Each chapter in the story shows us Clark at a different point in his life, and we follow his attempt to live a normal life while trying to help others in secret. Art-wise, Immonen turns in one of the best outings of his career, and the realism he brings to a story about a guy with super-powers fits the story perfectly. All told, it's an uplifting story that celebrates the triumph of living a good fulfilling life.

Rating: 4 (of 5)




Batman: Hong Kong

by Doug Moench & Tony Wong

After a series of death-by-snake-bite events are broadcast over the Internet, originating from both Gotham City and Hong Kong, Batman travels to the former British colony to uncover the mastermind, and ends up inspiring the birth of the Night Dragon, an armor-clad vigilante. The main attraction here is the art of superstar Hong Kong artist Tony Wong, and he certainly gets the chance to show his stuff. It's an odd combination of quasi-painted art and highly detailed pen-and-ink, usually on the same page, where some panels are painted and others are traditionally drawn. It's a method that emphasizes some panels over the others and makes for an interesting reading experience. The story by Moench is pretty much by-the-numbers. It takes little advantage of the opportunities that could be provided by setting the story in one of the most unique cities in the world, and the mystery of who is behind the killings is painfully obvious. Still, the purpose of the story was to give Wong cool things to draw, and in that is succeeds.

Rating: 3 (of 5)

"Hamlet Covered in Snot"

The Alan Moore BBC radio 4 interview can be heard online here. It's about half an hour long and contains many wonderful quotables, such as: "If I'm going to react, I may as well overreact."



(link via Fanboy Rampage.)

Help a Marvel Zombie

Over at his new blog Hey Grown Ups - Comics!, Phil Parr is looking for suggestions for indy comics that he might enjoy:

...my retailer doesn't carry independent titles and I don't have the dough to spend blindly out of Previews.



I so remember the joys of small press books. Please... save me! Tell me what I should be reading that doesn't come from the top five or six. More importantly... tell me why.

So how about it, comics blog-o-sphere--save Phil from Marvel Zombiedom!

The Five Manga Meme

From Sean (via Johanna, among others) all the cool kids are doing it: Here are my Top Five currently published manga in translation:



1. Planetes

2. Imadoki!

3. Blue Inferior

4. Hikaru-no Go

5. Negima



And as a bonus, because it's a completely different list, here are my Top Five all-time manga in translation:



1. Lone Wolf & Cub

2. Nausicaa

3. 2001 Nights

4. Maison Ikkoku

5. Sanctuary



(with honorable mention to Akira, Eagle, Uzumaki, Gon, Mai, and Paradise Kiss.)